Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Games & Tech

Morality in Red Dead Redemption 2

Our in-game choices make us feel guilty.

Red Dead Redemption 2
Credit: Rockstar Games

I’ve been playing Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) for many many hours now and I want to make it clear that I think the game is fantastic, it’s not perfect but it’s pretty damn close. What piqued my interest in particular was how it made me feel when I was going about my day to day business of being an outlaw.

It obviously came as no surprise that I was going to be relieving people of their hard earned money, possessions or in one case sheep in order to progress in the game. Nor was it a surprise that on many occasions I had to get heavy-handed and hurt or kill people in order to accomplish my task. What did surprise me is that on many occasions I felt guilty whilst doing it.

You can check out an official trailer below:

The life of an outlaw in RDR2 is tough and the fight for survival if fraught with danger what with the constant threat of rival gangs, Pinkerton detectives after your hide and the occasional wild animal attack, and your character Arthur Morgan has to be a tough son of a gun to survive and provide for his gang.

Rockstar have done a great job in humanising Arthur and his companions and I really got the feeling that everyone is tired of being on the run. Your gang members aren’t just grizzly cowboy stereotypes, they are families with wives and children in tow. One mission even has you taking a young boy fishing as his father can’t be bothered doing it. Even though he isn’t the leader of the gang Arthur certainly takes on the role of father and provider and this made me feel responsible for the people back at camp. The dialogue between characters also increases this feeling of being sick of the outlaw life and what they have to do to survive.

red dead redemption 2

© Rockstar Games

In stark contrast to this role are the dirty tasks the various missions have you doing. The first instance of guilt I felt was just after a sharpshooter side mission where a wrong button press had me draw my pistol on my competitor, he was unimpressed with this choice and opened fire on me and I was left with no choice but to fill him with lead and loot his corpse all whilst feeling slightly ashamed.

Another mission that stood out was the first train robbery I committed. Whilst walking down the carriage casually robbing people some people weren’t too happy about the situation and were resisting, up steps Arthur to offer a little persuasion via the butt of his rifle. I’m not offended as such by this violence, I bought the game with open eyes and having played RD1 and all the GTA games I knew what I’d be getting up to, I just didn’t expect to feel bad about it. I don’t know if it’s the fact that the actions aren’t automated, you have to press the button to hit someone or kill them, I think it’s the fact that ultimately it was my decision to carry out these acts.

red dead redemption 2

© Rockstar Games

All of this bad behaviour is also in contrast to the honour system within the game whereby you are rewarded by doing nice things for people such as rescuing people hanging from cliffs, a woman trapped under a dead horse or helping people finish building their house. I’m not sure if I completed these tasks because I wanted to be a nice guy or because I thought there might (and there often is) a reward for doing so.

As I said at the start this is an amazing game and I have already sunk hours into it, if I ever complete it I might even submit a review! In the meantime I’m sure I’ll still go about my daily task of robbing and killing without losing any sleep over it but I think it speaks to the power of the video game medium that it has provoked such feelings.

red dead redemption 2

© Rockstar Games

Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now on Xbox One and PS4.

You can check out the official pages here.


You May Also Like


The pop legends release their best album yet.


The acclaimed psychologist's follow-up is published by Allen Lane in hardback, eBook and audio on 2nd March.

Copyright © 2020 Entertainment Focus

Entertainment Focus is a trading name of Piñata Media Limited (Reg no: 08435639)

Entertainment Focus uses affiliate links. By buying through the links we may receive a commission for the sale. This has no effect on the price for you